Oversight? Or gaming the system?

| Print |  Email
Monday, July 14, 2014

AmazonBY VIVIAN MCINERNY | OB BLOGGER

Some people think Amazon’s winking eye logo is starting to look like a hoodwink.

On Thursday the Federal Trade Commission filed a lawsuit that could force the amazonian company to refund customers who may have been duped by somewhat sketchy practices. At issue is whether the company billed for in-app charges without the consent of the account holder. How is that even possible? Easy as stealing candy from a baby. Or maybe more accurately, easy as asking a baby if he’d like some candy, and then charging Mom and Pop for the sweet stuff.

Amazon apparently offers several game apps for children. The kids can play for a while for free before being asked if they’d like to purchase additional tokens, treasures or whatnots to continue. Kid presses yes, parents get charged. One parent complained that her young child wasn’t able to read yet, let alone agree to a credit card charge.

It’s easy to wag fingers at the parents for not knowing what their kids are doing on those ubiquitous smart phones and tablets. But did I sit and watch every episode of Sesame Street with my kids?  For all I know, while I was making a cup of tea in the kitchen Bert and Ernie taught the tots how to hot wire a car for a joy ride. It may have been parental guilt or embarrassment that allowed the game to keep going as long as it did. When parents complained about bills, some as high as $300, Amazon often forgave the debt and eventually responded to the problem by changing the apps so that when junior hit $20 in charges, Mom and Pop were notified. That sounds like a responsible company response, right?

The thing is, parents are less likely to complain about an unauthorized $19.99 charge. Most probably just suck it up and pay it before deleting the games or making sure their kids fully understand the difference between free virtual tokens and virtual tokens that look, sound and function just like free ones but cost actual money. And while they are at it, they might explain the savings and loan scandal to the tykes.

Apple settled a similar complaint with the FTC earlier this year.

If the FTC gets its way, in the future any and all in-app purchase will require approval from the actual account holder, and not just any pudgy little finger that manages to press a button.

Some of Amazon’s very own employees made similar suggestions to the powers that be, according to the FTC suit. The people working in call centers who had to deal directly with angry customers, I suspect, came up with the solution pretty quickly: If you want to charge customers, it’s probably a good idea to let them know.

No matter who wins the FTC versus Amazon battle, there’s a lesson to be learned. It’s dangerous to get smug at the top. High ranking officers would be wise to pay attention to what those in the trenches are saying. The Brass, the Suits or, perhaps in the case of Amazon, The Cleaner Sweatshirts may understand complex strategic planning, dividend yields and amortization of intangibles but they shouldn’t dismiss the knowledge of their foot soldiers. Put another way, since I’m mixing metaphors like milkshakes, remember that every rung on the corporate ladder contributes to its strength.

If in the future Amazon is required to notify customers of all in-app charges, it is sort of good news/bad news for the rest of us. The good: No surprise bill. The bad? Imagine the melt-downs in restaurants and airplanes when little Noah or Sophia is told no.

Mama and Papa may decide that the magic acorn needed to save the hungry chipmunk or whatever, is well worth another dollar.


 

Vivian McInerny blogs on popular culture for Oregon Business.

 

Comments   

 
Guest
0 #1 Dear VivianGuest 2014-07-18 03:12:38
Enjoyed your article very much. There are enough scams without a legitimate (?) company entering the "S" field.
Another good subject to delve into may be the over-sixty-two mortgage gimmick. Most banks and other financials are paying out big bucks for so-called celebrities to hawk their goods, such as former Senator Thompson of Tennnesee.

Your writing has always been delightful to read and follow, keep it up.
Uncle
Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
Guest
0 #2 Author respondsGuest 2014-07-19 22:28:26
Thank-you for your kind words.

Marketing reverse mortgages to older adults would make a good topic for a future blog. My new retirement plan: Become a "celebrity' spokesperson.
Quote | Report to administrator
 

More Articles

Credit Unions Perspective

June 2015
Tuesday, May 26, 2015
BY KIM MOORE

A conversation with Gene Pelham, CEO of Rogue Credit Union.


Read more...

5 stats about Oregon fireworks

The Latest
Thursday, June 18, 2015
fireworksthumb001BY JACOB PALMER | DIGITAL NEWS EDITOR

Fireworks are a booming industry, even if the pyrotechnics have turned July 4th into a day fire marshals, and many residents, love to hate.


Read more...

100 Best Green Workplaces announced

News
Wednesday, May 27, 2015
OBM-100-best-Green-logo-2015-1000pxwBY LINDA BAKER | EDITOR

More than 250 people turned out today for Oregon Business magazine’s seventh annual celebration of the 100 Best Green Companies to Work For in Oregon.


Read more...

Photo Diary: Forest Grove Farmers Market

The Latest
Thursday, May 14, 2015
IMG 8469BY JASON E. KAPLAN | STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER

There are more than 160 farmers markets in Oregon, contributing an estimated $50 million in sales, according to the Oregon Farmers Markets Association. We checked in on the Forest Grove market, which for several years has brought local produce and food vendors to Main Street in the center of town.


Read more...

The Green Paradox

June 2015
Friday, May 22, 2015
BY EMILY LIEDEL

Inside the topsy-turvy world of corporate sustainability rankings.


Read more...

Downtime with John Helmick

June 2015
Tuesday, May 26, 2015
BY JACOB PALMER

Live, Work, Play: CEO of Gorilla Capital.


Read more...

Fixing Oregon’s broken roads

The Latest
Tuesday, June 09, 2015
RUCCostComparison rev4-30BY KIM MOORE | RESEARCH EDITOR

The technology at the center of Oregon’s road usage fee reform.


Read more...
Oregon Business magazinetitle-sponsored-links-02
SPONSORED LINKS