|| Print ||
|Monday, February 28, 2011|
By Bill Conerly
A loyal reader asks if cutting government spending could possibly help create jobs. He's skeptical. The short answer is austerity does not help the economy in the usual Keynesian models--but there's reason to doubt them.
Here's a short lesson in the history of economic thought. John Maynard Keynes developed a theory that found government spending could significantly boost or contract the economy. That became part of the established body of economic thought.
Early critis of Keynes (pictured to the right) argued that he had not fully considered "crowding out" whereby government borrowing pushes up interest rates, crowding out private sector (and especially corporate) borrowing, leading to reduced investment in capital equipment. Actually, Keynes had addressed the issue and decided that when sales are very low, companies are hesitant to expand capacity at any interest rate.
Other challenges to Keynes came from the monetarist school, led by Milton Friedman, which didn't attack the theory so much as say that money had a much larger impact on the economy than did government policy. This view became the established theory in the 1980s and 1990s (and I'm simplifying tremendously).
A frontal assault on government spending as a stimulus came from a great modern economist, Robert Barro (who has been named as a possible Nobel laureate). Barro argues that taxpayers anticipate future tax bills. When they see large deficits, they assume they'll eventually have to pay the bill. They cut spending now to build up reserves to cover their future tax liability. This idea was first posited by the great 19th century economist David Ricardo.
Immediately after Barro published the theory, which we call Ricardian Equivalence, I laughed. "Yeah, people are that rational that they figure out their future taxes years in advance. Ha ha ha."
I'm not laughing too hard now. Here's what I'm saying in my speeches: The deficit is huge. It may improve a little with economic growth, but then the boomers start retiring, collecting Social Security. And they get Medicare. Then new hips, knees, hearts, etc. Over time, deficits continue to expand. (The social security component at least levels out as a share of GDP, but Medicare continues to worsen as health care inflation and utilization rates continue to push costs beyond revenues.)
I do not expect the Federal Reserve to allow enough inflation that the debt is effectively repudiated. And I do not expect the government to officially repudiate the debt, as some Latin American countries have done. Instead, I expect that taxes will rise. There may also be some entitlement reform, but most of the deficit cutting will come from higher taxes.
In my speeches on the economic outlook, I predict higher taxes in the coming decade, and I advise audiences to save more. Their nest eggs will produce fewer after-tax spendable dollars when tax rates rise, so larger nest eggs are needed.
I am advising people to follow that theory I laughed at: spend less now because taxes are going up.
The calculation of future tax burdens is not at all formal or precise. It's a gut feeling. And I think it is truly at work, especially among middle and upper income families. I hear it a lot from people I speak to.
That's how cutting government spending can help jobs. People would like to feel confident that the government is operating prudently, responsibly. I doubt that anyone, left or right, would use those words right now.
|The 100 Best Companies to Work For in Oregon|
|Help Wanted: Poached Jobs aids restaurateurs |
|How Oregon will survive the loss of Hanjin|
|On the Brink|
|Thy neighbor's house|
|How a Utah-based essential oils company cornered the Oregon market|
|Obama's veto of Keystone XL pipeline withstands Senate override attempt|
|Production of larger iPad delayed|
|McDonalds pledges to stop selling chicken raised with antibiotics|
|Uber invests in mapping software, setting up contention with Google|
|Bill Gates leads Forbes' richest people list|
|Oil continues to gain on supply risks|
|With AmEx out, Costco turns to Visa, Citi|
Generations of students and graduates have been plagued by the question: What is my true calling in life? Four alumni from Corban University’s Hoff School of Business who graduated in different decades say the school helped them find the answer by giving them a practical, well-rounded education.
It’s happening whether anyone’s ready or not. Businesses here in Oregon and across the U.S. are already experiencing the effects of the largest generational shift in recent history, and these changing tides will impact every level of the workplace — from a company’s executive leadership to its cultural core.
Success stories spotlight meaningful career opportunities in Oregon's diverse and lucrative tourism industry.
Parkinson's Resources of Oregon (PRO) is pleased to announce, long standing Intel manager, Kelly Sweeney has joined the agency’s Board of Directors as a member at large.
Local businesses interested in offering retail items, food and beverage, or passenger services at Portland International Airport are invited to attend one of two meetings on March 17.
The Firm was recognized for the strength of its case matters during 2014, including precedents set or verdicts with notable high dollar amounts at stake.