Timber split

| Print |  Email
Articles - April 2013
Monday, April 01, 2013
0413 TimberSplit 05
Warm Springs Forest Products Industries supplies its mill in Jefferson County with logs from both eastern and western Oregon.
// Photo by Oregon Forest Resources Institute

Given the polarization in the west, there is some debate about whether Kitzhaber’s proposal will ever take off. And even in the east, Wyden’s proposed legislation does not satisfy everyone. Many timber officials grumble that Wyden threw the industry a bone; the “stewardship” strategy gave the environmentalists everything they asked for, including protection of larger trees, no clearcutting and other measures to protect watersheds and wildlife.

There are other unknowns, including the U.S. Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management, which control 60% of all Oregon forests and 70% of the forestlands in the east. They would have to agree to increased logging. The Malheur contract would also have to be the first of many to reignite the industry. Loggers and mill workers have retired or moved away, so their ranks would need to be filled once again for the plan to work.

Many of the mills that once finished eastern Oregon trees have closed, and substantial investment dollars would be needed to re-create the infrastructure, adds Charles McKetta, a principal with the Boise-based consulting firm Forest Econ and a co-author of The 2012 Forest Report for the Oregon Forest Resources Institute — a document that goes to great lengths to outline the east-west divide. Mill investors are leery because of the uncertainties surrounding the timber harvesting issue and the viability of thinning strategies as the key to reviving the industry, McKetta says.

Despite these hurdles, many believe stewardship/maintenance is the first step toward a harvest compromise in the east — a first step that has yet to be taken in the west. In the end, it’s hard to escape the irony of that geographic split. In the east, where the industry has been decimated by years of logging restrictions, a clear and undeniable crisis exists. Now a model for reviving that region’s industry is emerging. Environmentalists, timber executives, politicians and community leaders are finding a meeting of the minds and are cautiously moving ahead with a strategy that could — could — create jobs, produce taxes, support communities and restore bone-dry, choked, fire-prone forests to health.

But in the west, where the infrastructure to support tree harvesting and processing remains largely in place, where trees continue to be cut, though in declining numbers, the crisis is not so palpable. The parties are dug into their positions, extremely wary of one another. The industry staunchly defends its right to harvest larger timber, while conservation groups just as steadfastly marshall the forces to thwart them. Meantime, mills run at far below capacity as communities slip further into poverty.

Wyden and Kitzhaber’s proposals both acknowledge that the disparate parties involved in the timber harvest debate share common interests. The environmentalists want healthier forests, the mill owners want trees, and stewardship means removing and processing trees and reinvigorating the forests. But whether a settlement in western Oregon can be negotiated in the absence of a complete industry collapse remains a troubling question. Meanwhile, in the east, the opposing parties seem to have reached an understanding — that a crisis is too good an opportunity to waste.

Dan Cook is a Portland-based freelance writer. He can be reached at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .



 

Comments   

 
Guest
0 #1 mixed messagesGuest 2013-04-18 22:11:16
I keep learning as I travel how far in the forefront Oregon is in recycling and applauding our “Green” businesses. I was in Utah recently, they don’t recycle at all – they get bigger garbage cans. Oregonians are striving to cut down on plastic bags and switch to paper bags. While in China I traveled into the farm lands and was shocked at the amount of plastic bags along the roads, mixed in the dirt in the fiels, piled on the sides of their streams. Then in Vietnam something else really hit home – granite. They are tearing down their extremely artistic granite hills at an alarming speed. Marble is another product of the earth that is being used for everything from kitchen and bathroom counters to statues of Buddha. Mining and rock crushing also leave huge and permanent scars on our earth.

Then I ask why some people are against using wood for building homes, schools, buildings, etc. It is biodegradable, naturally reproduces itself, can also be planted for another harvest in 40 to 60 years does not harm the environment, can be used to produce electricity instead of blocking our rivers and is one of Oregon’s chief natural resources for producing financial growth. It’s perfect. Oregon is lucky.

One little side note – a little motor scooter puts out more harmful emissions than a wood burning co-generation plant that produces enough electricity to supply 13,000 homes.
Quote | Report to administrator
 

More Articles

Stemming the tide of money in politics

Linda Baker
Wednesday, June 10, 2015
 jeff-lang-2012-thumbBY LINDA BAKER

Jeff Lang and his wife Rae used to dole out campaign checks like candy.  “We were like alcoholics,” Lang says. ”We couldn’t just give a little.”


Read more...

Reader Input: Energy Overload

June 2015
Wednesday, July 15, 2015

We asked readers to weigh in on the fossil fuel-green energy equation.


Read more...

House of Clarity

July/August 2015
Monday, July 13, 2015
BY JACOB PALMER

Holding a Power Lunch at Veritable Quandary in downtown Portland.


Read more...

Storyteller in Chief: Natural Prophets

July/August 2015
Monday, July 13, 2015
BY SAM BLACKMAN

Storyteller-in-chief with the CEO and co-founder of Elemental Technologies.


Read more...

Best Foot Forward

July/August 2015
Monday, July 13, 2015
BY CHRIS NOBLE

Whether you're stepping out to work or onto the track, Pacific Northwest shoe companies have you covered.


Read more...

Fixing Oregon’s broken roads

The Latest
Tuesday, June 09, 2015
RUCCostComparison rev4-30BY KIM MOORE | RESEARCH EDITOR

The technology at the center of Oregon’s road usage fee reform.


Read more...

5 stats about Oregon fireworks

The Latest
Thursday, June 18, 2015
fireworksthumb001BY JACOB PALMER | DIGITAL NEWS EDITOR

Fireworks are a booming industry, even if the pyrotechnics have turned July 4th into a day fire marshals, and many residents, love to hate.


Read more...
Oregon Business magazinetitle-sponsored-links-02
SPONSORED LINKS