Independent pharmacies struggle

| Print |  Email
Articles - August 2011
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
0811_Pharmacies_04
Paulsen’s soda fountain, which sells root beer floats for $2.75, attracts local business people as well as students from nearby Grant High School. // Photo by Eric Näslund

Like many independent pharmacists, Balo belongs to a wholesale provider group, in his case the Good Neighbor Pharmacy, a brand that gives members access to private-label purchasing, marketing materials and managed care networks. The store’s niche products and services include free home delivery, specialized “bubble packing” that allows seniors to keep track of medications in their homes, and customized drug preparations that range from cancer medications to veterinary antibiotics. Hard-to-find skin care creams, Medicare-approved “durable medical supplies,” and an old-time soda fountain featuring $2.75 root beer floats add to the offerings.

Like most independents, the bulk of Paulsen’s annual pharmacy sales, about 85%, come from prescription drugs — the national average is around 94%. Chain stores, by contrast, rely more on “front end” merchandise such as food and toiletries that can be marked up to compensate for flat rate drug reimbursement or dispensing fees.

Market diversification gives the Rite Aids of the world an edge. Nevertheless, in the David vs. Goliath tale community pharmacists like to spin about themselves, the giant is not so much the chains — or the government — as the pharmacy benefit managers. Most independents have contracts with the three biggest PBMs — Medco Health Solutions, Caremark and Express Scripts —but typically have little control over the terms. “The medicine might cost $200 and the contract pays us $202,” says Ann Murray, who, with her husband, John, owns two Murray’s Drugs, one in Condon and another in Heppner. “Most businesses have to make 20% to cover overhead,” Murray says. “You can’t expect pharmacies to survive by giving it away.”

The biggest problem with PBMs is they push consumers toward their own mail-order pharmacies, says John Murray. When the PBMs sell direct, they are able to negotiate better rates with drug manufacturers, and offer deals such as a three-month supply of medication for the cost of one. In the last few years, Murray estimates he’s lost about 20%-50% of his prescription business to mail order.

Aimed at reducing costs, mail order actually increases waste, Murray and other pharmacists contend, because patients change prescriptions before 90 days or because people take the medicine improperly. PBMs counter with their own studies saying that people are more likely to take medicines when by ordered by mail  — and that mail order saves consumers and health plan sponsors money. “Independents always argue that we’re squeezing them out of business,” says Thom Gross, a spokesperson for Express Scripts, adding that independents are actually more profitable than other drug channels, including PBMs.

The National Community Pharmacists Association is engaged in an ongoing battle with the PBMs, an effort that includes lawsuits related to deceptive practices and unfair competition. Pennsylvania and New York are also considering legislation prohibiting PBMs from mandating their customers use mail order.

 



 

Comments   

 
James
0 #1 Oregon bought into an invalid method to calculate Acquisition costJames 2011-09-23 09:53:28
Myers & Stauffer conducts a survey approach to determine pharmacist acquisition cost which is invalid by the time the information is collected, compiled and reported. It is skewed in the direction of the chain pharmacies because they report 2/3 of the data. Why not use a real-time system that costs the state almost nothing. Just go to www.pharmabayonline.com
Quote | Report to administrator
 

More Articles

Free Falling

Contributed Blogs
Thursday, December 18, 2014
121714-oilprice-thumbBY JASON NORRIS | OB CONTRIBUTOR

The implosion of the energy complex: The best thing for low oil prices is low oil prices.


Read more...

Top stories in 2014

The Latest
Thursday, December 18, 2014
10-listthumb

2014 was a year of wild contradictions, fast-paced growth and unexpected revelations.


Read more...

See How They Run

January-Powerbook 2015
Friday, December 12, 2014
BY LINDA BAKER

Studying ground-running birds, a group that ranks among nature's speediest and most agile bipedal runners, to build a faster robot.


Read more...

A legislative preview — and celebration

News
Friday, January 23, 2015
012315-speaker-thumbBY LINDA BAKER | OB EDITOR

The Northwest Environmental Business Council previews the 2015 legislative agenda as Hatch Oregon celebrates Oregon's new community crowdfunding rules.


Read more...

The Human Factor

February 2015
Monday, January 26, 2015
BY BRIAN LIBBY

Matt French opens up South Waterfront.


Read more...

Tackling the CEO-worker pay gap

January-Powerbook 2015
Thursday, December 11, 2014
BY OREGON BUSINESS STAFF

An SEC rule targets the disparity between executive and employee compensation, reigniting a long-standing debate about corporate social responsibility.


Read more...

Old school: Paulsen's Pharmacy maintains old fashion ethos

The Latest
Thursday, December 18, 2014
121914-pharmacy-thumbBY MEGHAN NOLT

VIDEO: Under the radar — complete with a soda counter, the traditional Paulsen's Pharmacy looks to compete with big box retailers.


Read more...
Oregon Business magazinetitle-sponsored-links-02
SPONSORED LINKS